GreatFlorida Homeowner's Insurance®

Mary Jo Noftsker, Fort Myers, FL. 33903

33 reviews

1621 N Tamiami Trail Suite 5
Fort Myers FL 33903

(239) 599-2481

Get a Quote

ShowHide agency details & hours keyboard_double_arrow_down

1621 N Tamiami Trail

Suite 5

Fort Myers, FL. 33903

Areas Served

Fort Myers

Additional Contact

Toll Free: 888.478.7801

Languages

English

Social

Mary Jo Noftsker: GreatFlorida Insurance Agency Owner

Office Hours

Our Reviews...

Vicky Strine

Jul 01, 2025

I stopped in Great Florida Insurance where I found Mary Jo Noftsker and I have and will tell everyone I can to contact her regarding any insurance issue or need they may have. I was at my wits end - feeling totally abandoned and taken advantage of by insurance companies. My need was to clear up a car insurance issue and honestly drop a company I felt had totally failed me - I was very upset when I arrived and let me tell you, Mary Jo not only took care of that issue/problem but also helped with our homeowners insurance and all things combined saved us so much! I cried multiple times in her office I had no idea someone could be so helpful and caring when it came to insurance. I just thought "we were screwed". No - folks - you are not!! Go see Mary Jo - not only will she help you but she will have you feeling like someone truly cares and will change your mind about insurance companies!!

Peter Gostout

May 19, 2025

Ivan and Michele were extremely helpful. Purchasing insurance can be stressful. This was not the case with this office. Both guided me through the process and made sure I received the right insurance for my needs. They answered all my questions and made me feel comfortable. I highly recommend this incredibly professional team!

Jaime Randall

May 16, 2025

I’ve been working with Mary Jo for over four years now, and it’s easy to see why she came so highly recommended. While many of my friends have been stressing over rising insurance rates, Mary Jo has consistently helped me find excellent coverage at affordable prices. Her knowledge, dedication, and personalized service truly set her apart. Thank you, Mary Jo!

Eva Krcil

May 08, 2025

After being dropped by previous insurance and having claim (result of hurricane Irma), it seemed impossible to find reliable insurance for our old home. Mary Jo did it and we are very grateful.

Albert Riendeau

May 08, 2025

Good experience

Valerie Dobbins

Apr 24, 2025

Mary Jo and Ivan are wonderful agents, they got me out of a bind quickly and I'm very grateful. I also met the owner, Mary Michele and she very welcoming and cares a great deal about her customers and employees. A+ service!

Michele Egiziaco-Davies

Aug 18, 2020

Customer did not leave a comment...

Glicelle Torres

Sep 20, 2024

Great Co, needed a quote and they responded quickly and very affordable. Thank you

Greg Cline

Aug 23, 2024

Mary Jo at Great Florida Insurance has been fantastic from the very start switching over all of our insurance needs. So glad we switched. Then she always makes sure we have the best coverage, by the best companies, and the best possible rate. And when updates are necessary, she's on top of it. She responds quickly to every email or phone call. I highly recommend her.

Fort Myers Homeowner's Insurance

Mary Jo Noftsker - GreatFlorida Insurance
Your Fort Myers Home Insurance Agent

Owning a home in Fort Myers is a major investment—make sure it’s protected with the right Home Insurance coverage tailored to Florida homeowners.

At GreatFlorida Insurance, we understand the unique challenges that come with homeownership in Fort Myers, from hurricane risks to flooding and everything in between. Our customized policies help safeguard your property, personal belongings, and financial future.

Choosing an online policy without professional guidance may leave coverage gaps or include protections you don’t need. Work with a local agent who knows Fort Myers and will ensure your coverage fits your home and lifestyle.

Why Fort Myers Homeowners Trust GreatFlorida Insurance:

Local Knowledge: As part of the Fort Myers community, we understand the specific risks in your area, including storms, wind damage, and flood exposures.

Tailored Coverage: Whether you own a single-family home, condo, or townhouse, we craft policies that cover your structure, possessions, and liability—without paying for extras you don’t need.

Dedicated Service: Our experienced agents provide personalized support, answering your questions and guiding you through policy options Monday through Friday.

Trusted Florida Partner: With more than 30 years of experience and strong relationships with top Florida insurance carriers, we help homeowners in 33903 secure the best coverage at competitive rates.

Protect your most valuable asset with confidence. Contact Mary Jo Noftsker at GreatFlorida Insurance in Fort Myers or request a quote today to safeguard your home and family.